How to Make Pie in Grow a Garden

Not sure how to make pie in Grow a Garden? With our guide, you can find all the known recipes for baking pies in Grow a Garden so far. While you’re here, take a look at our How to Make Salad guide, too!

How to Make Pie in Grow a Garden

Fancy baking a scrumptious pie? Weirdly enough, ingredients you wouldn’t expect to be in a pie are required when baking them in Grow a Garden. Keep in mind that these aren’t all the recipes! Players, including us, are trying to experiment with various crops to see if we can make new pies!

Rarest Pie Recipes

The more difficult the ingredients are to get, the rarer the pie, and the higher the quality.

Prismatic Rarity

The highest quality pies.

Method 1

• 1 Coconut
  • Costs 6K Sheckles from the Seed Shop
• 2 Bone Blossoms
  • Prehistoric event crop

Method 2

• 1 Sugar Apple
  • Costs 25 million Sheckles from the Seed Shop
• 3 Bone Blossoms
  • Prehistoric event crop
• 1 Sugarglaze
  • 10% chance from Gourmet Seed Pack

Method 3

• 1 Pumpkin
  • 12.5% chance from Normal Seed Pack
• 4 Bone Blossoms
  • Prehistoric event crop

Method 4

• 1 Sugar Apple
  • Costs 25 million Sheckles from the Seed Shop
• 1 Coconut
  • Costs 6K Sheckles from the Seed Shop
• 3 Bone Blossoms
  • Prehistoric event crop

Divine Rarity

The second rarest pies.

Method 1

• 3 Sugar Apples
  • Costs 25 million Sheckles from the Seed Shop
• 1 Pumpkin
  • 12.5% chance from Normal Seed Pack

Method 2

• 1 Sugarglaze
  • 10% chance from Gourmet Seed Pack
• 1 Beanstalk
  • Costs 10 million Sheckles from the Seed Shop

Method 3

• 1 Crown Melon
  • 20% chance from Gourmet Seed Pack
• 1 Fossilight
  • 0.5% chance from Ancient Seed Pack
• 1 Bone Blossom
  • Prehistoric event crop
• 2 Sugar Apples
  • Costs 25 million Sheckles from the Seed Shop

Method 4

• 1 Prickly Pear
  • Costs 555K Sheckles from Summer Merchant
• 1 Giant Pinecone
  • Costs 55 million Sheckles from the Seed Shop
• 1 Burning Bud
  • Costs 40 million Sheckles from the Seed Shop
• 1 Coconut
  • Costs 6K Sheckles from the Seed Shop
• 1 Bone Blossom
  • Prehistoric event crop

Method 5

• 2 Elder Strawberries
  • Costs 70 million Sheckles from the Seed Shop
• 1 Coconut
  • Costs 6K Sheckles from the Seed Shop
• 1 Firefly Fern or Celestiberry
  • Firefly Fern – 4.5% chance from Ancient Seed Pack
  • Celestiberry – Costs 15 million Sheckles from the Seed Shop
• 1 Pepper
  • Costs 1 million Sheckles from the Seed Shop

Mythical Rarity

A bit easier to make than Divine pies!

Method 1

• 1 Ember Lily
  • Costs 15 million Sheckles from the Seed Shop
• 1 Pumpkin
  • 12.5% chance from Normal Seed Pack

Method 2

• 1 Apple
  • Costs 3.25K Sheckles from the Seed Shop
• 1 Pumpkin
  • 12.5% chance from Normal Seed Pack

Method 3

• 3 Coconuts
  • Costs 6K Sheckles from the Seed Shop
• 1 Beanstalk
  • Costs 10 million Sheckles from the Seed Shop

Method 4

• 1 Beanstalk
  • Costs 10 million Sheckles from the Seed Shop
• 1 Pumpkin
  • 12.5% chance from Normal Seed Pack

Easy to Make Pies

These pies are the easiest to make as the required ingredients are fairly simple to obtain.

Legendary Rarity

High quality but easier to make.

Method 1

• 1 Tall Asparagus
  • 4.5% chance from Gourmet Seed Pack
• 1 Jalapeno
  • 25% chance from Gourmet Seed Pack
• 1 Twisted Tangle
  • Craftable crop
• 1 Crown Melon
  • 20% from Gourmet Seed Pack
• 1 Taco Fern
  • 4% from Chris P

Method 2

• 1 Pumpkin
  • 12.5% chance from Normal Seed Pack
• 1 Corn
  • Costs 1.3K Sheckles from the Seed Shop
• 1 Apple
  • Costs 3.25K Sheckles from the Seed Shop
• 1 Giant Pinecone
  • Costs 55 million Sheckles from the Seed Shop

Method 3

• 1 Moon Melon
  • Costs 500K Sheckles during the Blood Moon event
• 1 Pumpkin
  • 12.5% chance from Normal Seed Pack

Method 4

• 1 Dragon Fruit
  • Costs 50K Sheckles from the Seed Shop
• 1 Coconut
  • Costs 6K Sheckles from the Seed Shop
• 1 Pepper
  • Costs 1 million Sheckles from the Seed Shop
• 1 Strawberry
  • Costs 50 Sheckles from the Seed Shop

Method 5

• 1 Pineapple
  • 5% chance from Summer Seed Merchant or Normal Packs
• 1 Pumpkin
  • 12.5% chance from Normal Seed Pack

Normal Rarity

The easiest pies!

Method 1

• 1 Pumpkin
  • 12.5% chance from Normal Seed Pack
• 1 Corn
  • Costs 1.3K Sheckles from the Seed Shop
• 1 Apple
  • Costs 3.25K Sheckles from the Seed Shop
• 1 Sugar Apple
  • Costs 25 million Sheckles from the Seed Shop
• 1 Giant Pinecone
  • Costs 55 million Sheckles from the Seed Shop

Adele Wilson

Editor

With experience working for GameRant and in SEO copywriting, Adele loves to combine her adoration for gaming with her writing craft. She'll talk your ear off about anything fantasy, and if she's not typing away at her desk, she's probably playing an RPG somewhere, watching anime, or reading a book.