Game: The Torment of Whitewall

If you were asked to take the last inbound ferry to an isolated island village where a mysterious monster keeps appearing at night to whisk away victims to an unknown, assumedly grizzly fate, you'd probably have some reservations, right? Well, one can only assume the townsfolk pay handsomely, because that is exactly what the protagonist of The Torment of Whitewall decides to do. Sadly, for both you and our hero, it may have been better to simply remain uninvolved.